1451: "The Dancing Plague of 1518"

HistoryPodcastScience
Written By JC

Interesting Things with JC #1451: "The Dancing Plague of 1518" – In the summer heat of 1518, hundreds danced themselves to death in the streets of Strasbourg. Was it hysteria, hunger, or something buried deep in the brain? Science still can’t say for sure.

Curriculum - Episode Anchor

Episode Title: The Dancing Plague of 1518

Episode Number: #1451

Host: JC

Audience: Grades 9–12, college intro, homeschool, lifelong learners

Subject Area: Neuroscience, Psychology, Medical History, Sociology, Historical Epidemiology

Lesson Overview

By the end of this lesson, students will be able to:

  • Define historical and medical terminology related to mass psychogenic illness and chorea.

  • Compare theories explaining the 1518 Dancing Plague using scientific and historical evidence.

  • Analyze the neurological and sociocultural mechanisms that could have contributed to mass involuntary behavior.

  • Explain how belief systems, environment, and brain science intersect in historical medical anomalies.

Key Vocabulary

  • Mass Psychogenic Illness (mass sy-KO-jen-ik ILL-ness) — A phenomenon where a group of people exhibit similar physical symptoms with no identifiable physical cause, often triggered by stress or fear.

  • Chorea (KOH-ree-uh) — A movement disorder causing involuntary, unpredictable body movements, often linked to conditions affecting the basal ganglia.

  • Basal Ganglia (BAY-suhl GANG-lee-uh) — Deep brain structures involved in motor control, habit formation, and emotion regulation.

  • Ergot Fungus (UR-got FUN-gus) — A toxic mold found on rye that produces alkaloids chemically similar to LSD; historically implicated in outbreaks of hallucinations or spasms.

  • Entrainment (en-TRAIN-ment) — The synchronization of brainwave activity with external rhythmic stimuli, such as music or repetitive sound.

Narrative Core

  • Open: Frau Troffea begins dancing uncontrollably in 1518 Strasbourg, igniting a baffling and terrifying chain of events.

  • Info: The dancing spreads to hundreds; municipal records describe the chaos; authorities respond with music, hoping to cure it.

  • Details: Theories emerge centuries later—mass hysteria, neurological disorders, toxic fungus, and rhythmic brain entrainment.

  • Reflection: The human brain, under stress, can turn belief into biology; our minds and bodies are not always under our conscious control.

  • Closing: These are interesting things, with JC.

A group of men and women in simple 16th-century clothing dance together outdoors, smiling and holding hands. The scene depicts participants of the 1518 Dancing Plague, showing joy and exhaustion as they move in a village setting under warm, golden light.

Transcript

In July of 1518, a woman named Frau Troffea (Frow TROH-fee-uh) stepped into a street in Strasbourg (STRAWZ-burg), then part of the Holy Roman Empire, and began to dance. She didn’t stop for hours—or days. Her husband begged her to rest, but her body wouldn’t obey.

Within a week, 34 others joined her. By August, more than 400 people were dancing through the streets, unable to stop. Some collapsed from exhaustion. Others died of heart failure or stroke. Records from the city council describe a strange sound at night—the echo of hundreds of feet striking stone.

Authorities believed it was divine punishment. So they hired musicians, hoping the afflicted might “dance it out.” The result was chaos. The rhythm only made things worse.

Centuries later, science still can’t agree on what happened. One theory is mass psychogenic illness—a contagious psychological response to extreme stress. Strasbourg had been battered by famine and disease. Fear spread faster than food. Under those pressures, belief can become biology.

Another theory blames the brain itself. Physicians like Paracelsus described symptoms resembling chorea (KOH-ree-uh)—involuntary spasms caused by disorders of the basal ganglia. Others suspected ergot fungus, a mold on rye that produces LSD-like chemicals. But grain records and autopsies show no sign of mass poisoning.

Modern neuroscience adds one more clue. Rhythmic sound can synchronize brainwaves, a process called entrainment. Combined with exhaustion, heat, and faith, it might have pushed some into an unstoppable feedback loop—bodies trapped in motion while minds cried for stillness.

By September, the dancing stopped as suddenly as it began. Survivors were taken to a shrine of Saint Vitus (VY-tus), the patron saint of dancers. The city recovered, but the question never did: what force can make a person lose command of their own body?

This story is a reminder that not every haunting comes from the outside. Sometimes, the terror begins within.

These are interesting things, with JC.

Student Worksheet

  1. What is one scientific explanation for the Dancing Plague of 1518, and what evidence supports it?

  2. How might rhythmic sound and brain entrainment have contributed to the outbreak?

  3. Compare chorea and mass psychogenic illness in terms of their symptoms and causes.

  4. Why did the authorities choose to bring in musicians? What was the unintended result?

  5. In your opinion, which theory is the most plausible? Justify your answer using at least two pieces of evidence from the episode.

Teacher Guide

Estimated Time:
60–90 minutes

Pre-Teaching Vocabulary Strategy:
Use a concept map or Frayer Model to define and visualize neurological and historical vocabulary terms.

Anticipated Misconceptions:

  • Students may confuse psychogenic illness with malingering or faking.

  • Students may assume ergot poisoning was confirmed, rather than just hypothesized.

  • The term "plague" may lead students to think of infectious disease rather than psychological or neurological causes.

Discussion Prompts:

  • Can the brain create physical symptoms from stress or belief?

  • How might faith and folklore influence collective behavior in times of crisis?

  • What modern events might resemble the Dancing Plague?

Differentiation Strategies:

  • ESL: Provide bilingual vocabulary handouts and simplified reading versions of the transcript.

  • IEP: Scaffold the transcript with paragraph-by-paragraph summaries and visual aids.

  • Gifted: Assign an additional task to research a similar mass event (e.g., Salem witch trials or Tanganyika laughter epidemic).

Extension Activities:

  • Neuroscience mini-lesson: Explore the role of the basal ganglia in movement.

  • Psychology extension: Case studies of mass hysteria or conversion disorder.

  • History tie-in: Compare with other medieval phenomena like flagellant movements or relic pilgrimages.

Cross-Curricular Connections:

  • Biology: Nervous system and motor control

  • Psychology: Groupthink, stress disorders

  • History: Holy Roman Empire, religious beliefs and governance

  • Sociology: Collective behavior and social contagion

Quiz

Q1. What city was the site of the Dancing Plague of 1518?
A. Vienna
B. Paris
C. Strasbourg
D. Berlin
Answer: C

Q2. What did the authorities do in an attempt to cure the dancers?
A. Sent them to a monastery
B. Hired musicians
C. Gave them medicine
D. Exiled them
Answer: B

Q3. Which brain structure is associated with movement and may explain the symptoms?
A. Cerebellum
B. Frontal cortex
C. Basal ganglia
D. Hippocampus
Answer: C

Q4. What is one discredited theory about the cause of the Dancing Plague?
A. Mass psychogenic illness
B. Brain entrainment
C. Ergot poisoning
D. Chorea
Answer: C

Q5. What is entrainment?
A. A medieval dance style
B. A method of punishment
C. Synchronization of brain activity with sound
D. A type of fungal infection
Answer: C

Assessment

  1. Open-Ended: Evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of at least two different theories explaining the Dancing Plague. Which do you find most compelling, and why?

  2. Open-Ended: Describe how science and belief systems both played roles in understanding (or misunderstanding) the events of 1518.

3–2–1 Rubric:

  • 3 = Accurate, complete, thoughtful

  • 2 = Partial or missing detail

  • 1 = Inaccurate or vague

Standards Alignment

U.S. Standards:

  • NGSS HS-LS1-3: Students explore feedback mechanisms within the nervous system and the physiological basis of involuntary movement.

  • CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RI.11-12.3: Analyze complex events and ideas (e.g., the neurological, social, and historical aspects of the Dancing Plague).

  • C3.D2.His.1.9-12: Evaluate historical sources to develop coherent explanations about the past.

  • CTE.HLTH.2.5 (Health Science Pathway): Analyze the connection between mental health and physical health.

  • ISTE 3a: Students plan and employ effective research strategies to locate information to solve authentic problems.

UK / International Equivalents:

  • AQA GCSE History: Paper 1 Section B – Medicine in Britain: Explore beliefs about causes and treatment of disease in historical context.

  • IB MYP Sciences Criterion B: Inquiring and designing — explore scientific theories around mass behavior.

  • Cambridge IGCSE Biology 0610, 2.2: Structure and function in living organisms — nervous system and involuntary response.

Show Notes

This episode explores one of the most bizarre medical mysteries in history: the Dancing Plague of 1518. With eerie precision, JC recounts how a woman’s inexplicable urge to dance sparked a collective episode that baffled the medical, religious, and political authorities of the time. Students will engage with both historical evidence and modern science—including neuroscience, psychology, and epidemiology—to evaluate theories ranging from mass hysteria to brain entrainment. This case study remains powerfully relevant in understanding how human biology and belief interact in times of collective stress, making it ideal for interdisciplinary investigation in modern classrooms.

References:

JC https://jimconnors.org
Previous

1452: "Okapi – The African Unicorn"
Next

1450: "The Alkonost"