1243: "Mystery of Dark Matter and Dark Energy"
Interesting Things with JC, Episode #1243: "Mystery of Dark Matter and Dark Energy" – Only 5% of the universe is visible. The rest? It’s hidden in plain sight. Explore the invisible forces shaping our universe.
-
Episode Title: Mystery of Dark Matter and Dark Energy
Episode Number: #1243
Host: JC
Audience: Grades 9–12, college intro, homeschool, lifelong learners
Subject Area: Physics, Astronomy, Cosmology -
By the end of this lesson, students will be able to:
Define key cosmological terms such as baryonic matter, dark matter, and dark energy.
Compare the characteristics and effects of dark matter and dark energy.
Analyze historical discoveries and their impact on our understanding of the universe.
Explain the importance of scientific inquiry in the absence of observable evidence.
-
Baryonic (BAIR-ee-ON-ik) matter — The "normal" matter composed of protons, neutrons, and electrons. It makes up only about 5% of the universe.
Dark Matter — Invisible mass that does not emit or absorb light but exerts gravitational force, holding galaxies together.
Dark Energy — A theoretical form of energy that causes the accelerating expansion of the universe.
Gravitational Lensing — The bending of light caused by massive objects, often used as evidence for dark matter.
Type Ia Supernova — A type of exploding star used as a "standard candle" to measure cosmic distances and detect universal expansion.
-
Open
The episode opens with the stunning statement that only 5% of the universe is made of known matter—provoking curiosity and awe.Info
We are introduced to Fritz Zwicky's 1933 observation of galaxy clusters moving too fast to be explained by visible matter, and to Vera Rubin’s 1970s galaxy rotation curve studies.Details
Modern cosmology now confirms dark matter and dark energy account for 95% of the universe. Instruments like LUX-ZEPLIN and the Roman Space Telescope are actively searching for more clues.Reflection
The episode reflects on how the mystery of the universe’s invisible components pushes the limits of the scientific method and human understanding.Closing
“These are interesting things, with JC.” -
Interesting Things with JC, Episode #1243: "Mystery of Dark Matter and Dark Energy"
Only 5 percent.
That’s how much of the universe is made up of baryonic (BAIR-ee-ON-ik) matter—protons, neutrons, and electrons. The tangible stuff. The things we can touch, measure, burn, break down, or build with. It includes stars, interstellar gas, planets, even us. All of it combined makes up less than a twentieth of everything that exists.
So, where’s the rest?
The short answer: we don’t know. But we’re trying.
The longer answer began almost a century ago, when Swiss-American astrophysicist Fritz Zwicky (ZWICK-ee), observing the Coma (KOH-mah) Cluster in 1933, calculated the mass of the galaxies using the virial theorem. He found that galaxies were orbiting the cluster's center so fast they should've torn free—unless there was hidden mass exerting gravitational pull. He called it dunkle Materie, or “dark matter.”
His claim was dismissed. But it didn’t go away.
In the 1970s, American astronomer Vera Rubin (ROO-bin) and Kent Ford studied the rotation curves of spiral galaxies like Andromeda. Using spectroscopic data, they measured the Doppler shifts of stars. Rubin discovered something profound: stars at the outer edges were moving just as quickly as those closer to the core. That violates Newtonian mechanics unless there’s an invisible mass halo—much larger than the luminous matter.
By the early 2000s, dark matter had gone from fringe theory to mainstream cosmology. It now accounts for roughly 27% of the universe's total mass-energy density.
But that’s not the most disturbing part.
In 1998, two independent research teams—the High-Z Supernova Search Team and the Supernova Cosmology Project—used Type Ia (one-A) supernovae as standard candles to calculate cosmic distances. They expected the expansion of the universe to be slowing. Instead, they found acceleration.
Something was working against gravity. Something they called dark energy.
Today, the ΛCDM (Lambda Cold Dark Matter) model—the standard cosmological model—tells us that the universe consists of 5% ordinary matter, 27% dark matter, and 68% dark energy.
So what is dark matter?
It doesn’t emit, absorb, or reflect electromagnetic radiation. It doesn’t interact with the strong or weak nuclear forces. It’s not antimatter, and it’s not black holes. It’s invisible, but its gravitational fingerprint is unmistakable.
The leading candidates are theoretical particles:
WIMPs (Weakly Interacting Massive Particles),
axions (AKS-ee-ons), ultralight particles proposed in quantum chromodynamics,
and sterile neutrinos, a hypothetical version of neutrinos that don’t interact via the weak force.
None have been conclusively observed.
What about dark energy?
It’s not a particle. It’s a property. Maybe a cosmological constant—a built-in feature of spacetime itself, as Einstein proposed. Or maybe it’s a dynamic field, sometimes called quintessence (KWIN-tuh-sense), that evolves over time. It could even be a sign that gravity behaves differently over vast scales, suggesting that general relativity is incomplete.
We’ve built billion-dollar machines to search for answers.
The Large Hadron Collider at CERN has tried to detect supersymmetric partners.
The LUX-ZEPLIN detector in South Dakota sits 1.5 kilometers (0.93 miles) underground, waiting for dark matter to interact with xenon.
NASA’s Roman Space Telescope—launching soon—will measure the effects of dark energy through weak gravitational lensing and baryon acoustic oscillations.
And yet, we’re still in the dark.
The effects are clear.
Dark matter bends light from distant galaxies—an effect called gravitational lensing.
It holds galaxies together.
Dark energy drives them apart.
But what they are, fundamentally? We don’t know.
This is more than a physics problem. It’s a reckoning.
Because if we can’t account for 95% of the universe, then everything we thought we understood about cosmology, entropy, even time’s arrow—might be a partial truth.
It challenges the scientific method itself—forcing us to build instruments to detect something we don’t even know how to define.
Some physicists now believe that dark energy may one day push the fabric of the cosmos to a “Big Rip,” where the expansion becomes so extreme that galaxies, stars, planets—even atomic structures—are pulled apart. Others suggest a gentler “Big Freeze,” a cosmic heat death with no more usable energy, just cold, dark silence.
Still others propose something cyclical—a universe that expands and contracts in perpetuity. But none of this is confirmed.
And yet… we search. Because discovery doesn’t start with knowledge—it begins with wonder.
The mystery of dark matter and dark energy doesn’t just expose our limits. It defines them. And in that darkness—in that absence of knowing—we find the reason to keep looking up.
These are, interesting things, with JC.
-
What percentage of the universe is composed of baryonic matter?
Who first proposed the idea of "dark matter," and what observation led to it?
Describe how Vera Rubin’s research provided evidence for dark matter.
What is the main difference between dark matter and dark energy?
Why is the discovery of the accelerating universe considered a major scientific turning point?
-
Estimated Time
60–75 minutesPre-Teaching Vocabulary Strategy
Introduce terms using real-world analogies (e.g., comparing dark matter to a hidden scaffolding holding structures in space).Anticipated Misconceptions
That “dark” means evil or dangerous—clarify it refers to being undetectable by light.
Confusing dark matter with black holes or antimatter.
Discussion Prompts
Why is it important to study things we cannot directly observe?
How have instruments helped us detect “invisible” parts of the universe?
What does the mystery of dark energy say about the limits of human knowledge?
Differentiation Strategies
ESL: Use visual glossaries for all new terms.
IEP: Provide guided notes with definitions and diagrams.
Gifted: Encourage independent research into particle physics theories like WIMPs or quintessence.
Extension Activities
Create a timeline of dark matter/dark energy discoveries.
Debate: “Is dark energy more important than dark matter?”
Build a model demonstrating gravitational lensing using everyday materials.
Cross-Curricular Connections
Physics: Laws of motion and gravitation
Mathematics: Measuring distance using standard candles
History of Science: Scientific revolutions and paradigm shifts
-
Q1. How much of the universe is made of dark energy?
A. 5%
B. 27%
C. 68%
D. 95%
Answer: CQ2. Who was the first scientist to suggest the existence of dark matter?
A. Vera Rubin
B. Fritz Zwicky
C. Albert Einstein
D. Edwin Hubble
Answer: BQ3. What kind of astronomical object was used in 1998 to study the universe’s expansion?
A. Black holes
B. Type Ia supernovae
C. Neutron stars
D. Pulsars
Answer: BQ4. What is the ΛCDM model?
A. A type of particle accelerator
B. A galactic measurement scale
C. The standard model of cosmology
D. A telescope
Answer: CQ5. What does gravitational lensing provide evidence for?
A. Black holes
B. Cosmic inflation
C. Dark matter
D. Time travel
Answer: C -
Explain how dark matter was discovered and how it continues to shape our understanding of galaxies.
In your own words, describe why the discovery of dark energy has been so disruptive to cosmology.
3–2–1 Rubric
3 = Accurate, complete, thoughtful
2 = Partial or missing detail
1 = Inaccurate or vague -
NGSS (Next Generation Science Standards)
HS-ESS1-2: Construct an explanation of the Big Bang theory based on astronomical evidence.
HS-PS2-4: Use mathematical representations of Newton’s Law of Gravitation.
HS-ESS1-4: Use evidence to explain the expansion of the universe.
CCSS (Common Core State Standards – Literacy in Science and Technical Subjects)
RST.11-12.2: Determine the central ideas of a scientific text.
RST.11-12.3: Analyze experiments and observations described in science texts.
C3 (College, Career, and Civic Life Framework for Social Studies)
D1.2.9-12: Explain points of agreement and disagreement experts have about interpretations and applications of scientific evidence.
IB (International Baccalaureate – DP Physics)
Topic 10.3: Cosmology – understanding redshift, cosmic background radiation, and the composition of the universe.
Cambridge International (IGCSE Physics 0625/0972)
Section 3.1: Motion of astronomical objects and gravity.
-
This episode of Interesting Things with JC explores one of the most mind-bending mysteries of modern physics: the existence and nature of dark matter and dark energy. Listeners learn how invisible forces shape our cosmos, hold galaxies together, and even accelerate universal expansion. By grounding abstract concepts in real discoveries—from Fritz Zwicky’s 1930s work to cutting-edge detectors—this episode brings science to life for students and lifelong learners. A vital topic for understanding both the known and the unknowable aspects of the universe.
Ref:
Borchardt, G. (2024). Solution of the dark matter riddle within standard model physics. Frontiers in Astronomy and Space Sciences, 11, Article 1413816. https://doi.org/10.3389/fspas.2024.1413816
