Interesting Things with JC #1842: "Edwin Hubble"
In 1923, astronomer Edwin Hubble photographed a star in Andromeda and discovered evidence that challenged the accepted size of the universe. His measurements showed that Andromeda existed beyond the Milky Way, while his later research helped establish that distant galaxies are moving apart. The discoveries changed astronomy, but the exact rate of cosmic expansion remains disputed today.
Curriculum - Episode Anchor
Episode Title: Edwin Hubble
Episode Number: 1842
Series: Interesting Things with JC
Host: JC
Publication Date: November 20, 2026
Audience: Grades 9–12, introductory college, homeschool, lifelong learners
Subject Area: Astronomy, astrophysics, cosmology, history of science, mathematics, scientific literacy
Instructional Duration: 45–55 minutes
Instructional Format: Audio-first, evidence-based inquiry
Central Theme: How astronomical observations transformed humanity's understanding of the size and expansion of the universe.
Lesson Overview
Essential Question: How did Edwin Hubble's observations change our understanding of the universe, and why do scientists continue to revise their measurements?
Learning Objectives
Students will be able to:
Explain how Cepheid variable stars allow astronomers to measure distances beyond the Milky Way.
Identify the contributions of Edwin Hubble, Henrietta Swan Leavitt, Vesto Slipher, Georges Lemaître, and Milton Humason to modern cosmology.
Interpret the relationship between galaxy distance and recession velocity using the Hubble–Lemaître law.
Evaluate how observational uncertainty, improved technology, and scientific collaboration influence astronomical conclusions.
Success Criteria
Students demonstrate understanding when they can:
Explain why Hubble's discovery of a Cepheid variable in Andromeda established that it was outside the Milky Way.
Correctly distinguish apparent brightness from intrinsic luminosity.
Interpret a basic galaxy distance versus recession velocity graph.
Explain why Andromeda can approach the Milky Way while the universe expands.
Use historical and scientific evidence to explain how discoveries build upon earlier research.
Student Relevance Statement: Modern science depends on careful observation, reliable measurements, and the willingness to correct earlier conclusions. Hubble's work demonstrates how evidence can overturn accepted assumptions.
Real-World Connection: Astronomers continue to use variable stars, telescope observations, and mathematical models to measure cosmic distances. Similar approaches to calibration, uncertainty, and data interpretation are used in engineering, medical imaging, satellite systems, and scientific research.
Workforce Reality: Astronomers, aerospace engineers, astrophysicists, data scientists, and scientific instrument technicians routinely combine observations, mathematical analysis, and independent verification.
Key Vocabulary
Core Scientific Terms
Cepheid Variable (SEE-fee-id VAIR-ee-uh-bul): A pulsating star whose regular changes in brightness reveal its intrinsic luminosity, allowing astronomers to calculate distance.
Luminosity (loo-muh-NOSS-ih-tee): The total energy a star radiates per unit of time, independent of its distance from an observer.
Apparent Brightness: The amount of light received from an astronomical object as observed from Earth.
Photographic Plate: A glass plate coated with light-sensitive material, historically used to record astronomical observations before electronic detectors became standard.
Galaxy: A gravitationally bound system containing stars, gas, dust, dark matter, and other astronomical objects.
Redshift: An increase in the wavelength of light toward the red end of the spectrum. Cosmological redshift occurs as light travels through expanding space.
Cosmic Distance Ladder: A sequence of overlapping techniques used to measure astronomical distances, beginning with nearby objects and extending to increasingly distant galaxies.
Hubble–Lemaître Law (HUB-ul luh-MEH-truh): The relationship describing how recession velocity generally increases with distance in an expanding universe.
Hubble Constant: The parameter representing the universe's present expansion rate, commonly expressed in kilometers per second per megaparsec.
Hubble Tension: The persistent disagreement between some measurements of the present expansion rate and values inferred from observations of the early universe.
Vocabulary Application
Students select 5 terms and construct a coherent explanation of how astronomers established that Andromeda was a separate galaxy and subsequently investigated cosmic expansion.
Extension: Distinguish between evidence, interpretation, uncertainty, and scientific consensus.
Narrative Core
Open — The Photograph That Changed Astronomy
On October 5–6, 1923, Edwin Hubble used the 100-inch (2.54-meter) Hooker telescope at Mount Wilson Observatory to photograph part of the Andromeda Nebula.
Initially, he identified several potential novae, marking them with the letter N. Subsequent comparison with other photographic plates revealed that one object was a Cepheid variable star.
Hubble crossed out its N designation and wrote VAR!, recording a finding that would fundamentally change the accepted scale of the universe.
Info — The Scientific Problem
During the early 20th century, astronomers disagreed about the nature of spiral nebulae.
Some believed these objects belonged to the Milky Way. Others proposed that they were separate stellar systems.
The disagreement was publicly debated in 1920 by Harlow Shapley and Heber Curtis.
To resolve the question, scientists needed dependable methods for measuring distances far beyond nearby stars.
Henrietta Swan Leavitt (LAY-vit) had established a critical relationship between the pulsation period and intrinsic luminosity of Cepheid variables.
Hubble applied that relationship to Andromeda.
His estimated distance exceeded the accepted dimensions of the Milky Way, demonstrating that Andromeda was an independent galaxy.
Details — Historical Chronology
1889: Edwin Powell Hubble is born on November 20 in Marshfield, Missouri.
1908–1912: Henrietta Swan Leavitt establishes and publishes the relationship between Cepheid pulsation periods and luminosity.
1912–1917: Vesto Slipher (SLY-fer) develops spectroscopic measurements showing substantial radial velocities among spiral nebulae.
1920: Harlow Shapley and Heber Curtis debate the size of the Milky Way and the nature of spiral nebulae.
1923: Hubble photographs and identifies the Cepheid variable V1 in Andromeda.
1925: Hubble's findings are presented at the American Astronomical Society meeting on January 1, confirming evidence for galaxies beyond the Milky Way.
1927: Georges Lemaître develops an expanding-universe model from general relativity and connects it with astronomical observations.
1929: Hubble publishes evidence demonstrating a relationship between galaxy distances and recession velocities.
1931: Hubble and Milton Humason (HUE-muh-sun) publish expanded observational results extending measurements to more distant galaxies.
1953: Hubble passes away on September 28 in San Marino, California.
1990: NASA launches the Hubble Space Telescope aboard Space Shuttle Discovery.
2018: The International Astronomical Union recommends the name Hubble–Lemaître law to recognize both scientists' contributions.
Scientific Principle — Measuring Distance
Cepheid variables change brightness with a predictable period.
Leavitt's relationship allows astronomers to estimate intrinsic luminosity from that period.
Comparing intrinsic luminosity with apparent brightness allows distance to be calculated.
For a fixed intrinsic luminosity, observed brightness decreases according to the inverse-square law:
\[ F=\frac{L}{4\pi d^2} \]
Where:
F: Observed energy flux.
L: Intrinsic luminosity.
d: Distance from the source.
For cosmological recession at relatively nearby distances, the Hubble–Lemaître relationship is approximated by:
\[ v=H_0d \]
Where:
v: Recession velocity in kilometers per second.
H₀: Present expansion rate.
d: Distance in megaparsecs.
One megaparsec equals approximately 3.26 million light-years.
Worked Example
For instructional purposes, use an illustrative expansion rate of 70 kilometers per second per megaparsec.
A galaxy located 50 megaparsecs away would have an approximate recession velocity of:
70 × 50 = 3,500 kilometers per second.
This simplified example demonstrates the mathematical relationship. It is not a reconstruction of Hubble's original measurements.
Reflection — Science Corrects Its Measurements
Hubble's early expansion estimate was approximately 500 kilometers per second per megaparsec.
Modern measurements are substantially lower, generally near 67–76 kilometers per second per megaparsec, depending on the measurement method.
The difference between contemporary approaches remains an active scientific problem.
An additional distinction concerns local gravity. The nearby Andromeda Galaxy is approaching the Milky Way despite the general expansion of the universe.
Students should understand that the universe's large-scale expansion does not require every pair of galaxies to move apart.
Closing
Hubble's achievement resulted from new observations combined with earlier discoveries, mathematical reasoning, and collaborative research. His surviving photographic plate provides a physical record of how one observation helped establish an entirely different picture of the universe.
These are interesting things, with JC.
Transcript
Podcast cover art for Interesting Things with JC, episode 1842, “Edwin Hubble.” A black-and-white portrait of astronomer Edwin Hubble holding a pipe appears against a star-filled sky featuring the Andromeda Galaxy. An astronomical photographic plate marked “VAR,” with a crossed-out “N,” references his 1923 discovery of a Cepheid variable star. Mount Wilson Observatory appears in the background. Large yellow lettering reads “Edwin Hubble,” with the subtitle “The Observation That Expanded the Universe.”
Interesting Things with JC #1842:
Edwin Hubble
On October 5, 1923, Edwin Hubble photographed a faint patch of light in Andromeda. Looking at the glass plate, he marked one star with an N, believing it was a nova. But after comparing it with other photographs, he crossed out the N and wrote VAR. He'd discovered a star that changed brightness in a regular pattern.
Just 3 years earlier, astronomers had debated whether objects like Andromeda were part of the Milky Way or existed somewhere beyond it. Hubble was looking for an answer using the 100-inch Hooker telescope at California's Mount Wilson Observatory.
The star he'd found was called a Cepheid variable. Years earlier, astronomer Henrietta Swan Leavitt had discovered that the time it takes one of these stars to brighten and dim tells astronomers how bright it actually is. By comparing that with how bright it looks from Earth, they could figure out how far away it was.
Hubble's calculations showed that Andromeda was much farther away than anyone believed the Milky Way extended. His original distance estimate wasn't quite right, but his conclusion was. Andromeda was another galaxy. His findings were presented publicly in January 1925.
Hubble kept studying distant galaxies, building on earlier work by astronomer Vesto Slipher, who'd noticed that light from many of them suggested they were moving away from us.
In 1927, Belgian physicist Georges Lemaître had already worked out a mathematical explanation for an expanding universe and connected it to observations.
Then, in 1929, Hubble published evidence showing that the farther away a galaxy was, the faster it generally appeared to be moving away.
He later worked with Milton Humason, a man who'd started at Mount Wilson driving mule teams before becoming a skilled astronomer himself.
Today, that relationship is called the Hubble–Lemaître law. It describes how space itself expands, increasing the distance between galaxies over time.
Hubble's original calculations put the expansion rate about 7 times higher than today's estimates because the distances weren't measured accurately enough. Even now, astronomers disagree about the exact rate, a problem known as the Hubble tension.
And here's something interesting. Andromeda is actually moving toward the Milky Way because gravity between the 2 galaxies is stronger than the effect of cosmic expansion at that distance.
Hubble was born on November 20, 1889, exactly 137 years ago today. He passed away in 1953, long before NASA launched the space telescope named in his honor.
And that original photographic plate still exists, complete with the crossed-out N and handwritten VAR. It's a record of the observation that helped astronomers discover just how much bigger the universe was than they'd imagined.
These are interesting things, with JC.
Student Worksheet
Student Name: __________________________
Date: __________________________
Class: __________________________
Instructions: Listen to the episode before answering. Respond using complete sentences and specific evidence. Refer to the provided transcript when necessary.
Comprehension
What did Hubble initially believe he had photographed in Andromeda, and what evidence changed his interpretation?
How did Henrietta Swan Leavitt's research help astronomers calculate cosmic distances?
What did Hubble's measurements demonstrate about Andromeda and the Milky Way?
Analysis
Explain how the 1920 debate over spiral nebulae illustrates the importance of evidence in scientific disagreements.
Why is it historically inaccurate to attribute the development of modern cosmology to Hubble alone? Identify at least 3 other contributors and explain their roles.
Why does Andromeda's movement toward the Milky Way not contradict the Hubble–Lemaître law?
Quantitative Reasoning
7. Using a hypothetical expansion rate of 70 kilometers per second per megaparsec, calculate the expected recession velocities for galaxies at:
10 megaparsecs
20 megaparsecs
40 megaparsecs
State the velocities in kilometers per second. Explain the pattern and identify why this model does not accurately describe every nearby galaxy.
Reflection
8. Hubble's original distance and expansion-rate calculations required major corrections. Explain whether these revisions weakened his fundamental discovery or demonstrated the ability of science to improve.
Difficulty Scaling
Level 1 — Foundational: Answer questions 1–3 and 8 using the episode and vocabulary.
Level 2 — Intermediate: Complete all comprehension and analysis questions, using evidence from the transcript.
Level 3 — Advanced: Complete all questions, justify the quantitative model, and investigate the limitations of historical astronomical measurements.
Student Output: Submit numbered responses, showing calculations where required. Recommended length: 300–450 words, excluding calculations.
Academic Integrity Guidance: Responses should reflect the student's own reasoning. Quote or paraphrase sources accurately and acknowledge external information. Calculators, reference materials, and digital research tools may support the assignment, but students must explain their reasoning independently.
Teacher Guide
Quick Start: Introduce the lesson by displaying Hubble's original Andromeda photographic plate or describing its markings. Ask students how one faint star could reveal the existence of galaxies beyond the Milky Way.
Play the complete episode before introducing technical explanations.
Pacing Guide — Audio First
0–5 minutes: Bell ringer and opening question.
5–9 minutes: Play the full episode.
9–16 minutes: Review Cepheid variables, luminosity, and observational evidence.
16–25 minutes: Historical chronology and scientific collaborators.
25–35 minutes: Quantitative exercise and discussion of cosmic expansion.
35–45 minutes: Student worksheet and assessment.
45–55 minutes: Optional extended discussion, source investigation, or exit ticket.
Bell Ringer
Ask students:
"If a distant object appears dim, does that necessarily mean it produces very little light?"
Students write a 2-sentence response before listening.
Audio Guidance
Play the complete episode without interruption.
Ask students to identify the moment Hubble realized his initial classification was incorrect.
On a second playback, students may identify names, discoveries, and dates.
Provide the transcript for accessibility and review.
Audio Fallback
If audio playback is unavailable, distribute the transcript and conduct a guided reading. Preserve the same questions and instructional sequence.
Time on Task: Core lesson: 45 minutes. Extended lesson: 55 minutes. Independent homework: approximately 20 minutes.
Materials
Episode audio or transcript.
Student worksheet.
Original Hubble photographic plate image, when available.
Paper, pencils, and calculator.
Optional graph paper or spreadsheet software.
Internet access for source verification, if available.
Vocabulary Strategy
Introduce the distinction between intrinsic luminosity and apparent brightness before discussing Cepheids.
Ask students to construct a sequence:
Pulsation period → Intrinsic luminosity → Apparent brightness comparison → Distance.
Common Misconceptions
* Misconception: Hubble discovered the existence of all galaxies by himself.
Correction: His observations helped establish that Andromeda lay beyond the Milky Way, building on the contributions of several astronomers.
* Misconception: A dim star must be a weak light source.
Correction: Apparent brightness depends on both luminosity and distance.
* Misconception: Every galaxy must move away from every other galaxy.
Correction: Gravitationally associated galaxies may approach or orbit each other.
* Misconception: Hubble directly measured the modern expansion rate.
Correction: His initial value was considerably higher because the distance scale required correction.
* Misconception: Scientific corrections automatically invalidate earlier discoveries.
Correction: Improved measurements often refine an established conclusion without overturning it.
Discussion Prompts
Why was a reliable distance measurement necessary to resolve the Andromeda debate?
What distinguishes the discovery of a mathematical relationship from the observations used to support it?
How should historical credit be shared among scientists?
What can the Hubble tension teach us about unresolved scientific questions?
Formative Checkpoints
Students explain the significance of VAR! in one sentence.
Students identify the contribution of Henrietta Swan Leavitt.
Students correctly predict the direction of change in recession velocity as distance increases.
Students distinguish Hubble's historical observations from modern interpretations.
Differentiation
Additional Support: Supply a labeled diagram connecting Cepheid period, luminosity, apparent brightness, and distance.
Advanced Learners: Introduce the inverse-square law and discuss the effects of measurement uncertainty.
English Learners: Provide phonetic vocabulary, sentence starters, and visual examples.
Students with Disabilities: Offer accessible transcripts, large-print graphs, calculator support, flexible response formats, and additional processing time.
Assessment Differentiation
Foundational: One explanatory paragraph supported by 2 scientific facts.
Intermediate: Two evidence-based paragraphs incorporating 3 historical contributors.
Advanced: A comparative explanation integrating observations, mathematical reasoning, uncertainty, and scientific collaboration.
Time Flexibility
30-minute version: Audio, vocabulary, questions 1–3, group discussion, exit ticket.
45-minute version: Complete core lesson and worksheet.
55-minute version: Add quantitative analysis and source comparison.
Extended assignment: Investigate an original astronomical source and prepare a 500-word report.
Substitute Readiness
The lesson requires no specialized astronomy expertise. A substitute can distribute the transcript, play the episode, supervise the worksheet, and administer the quiz using the answer key below.
Engagement Strategy
Present the original photographic plate without initially explaining the N and VAR! labels.
Have students propose what those markings might indicate, then compare their predictions with the historical record.
Extensions
Investigate Henrietta Swan Leavitt's work at Harvard College Observatory.
Compare Hubble's original estimate for Andromeda with its modern approximate distance of 2.5 million light-years.
Research differences between Cepheid-based and cosmic microwave background estimates of the Hubble constant.
Construct a graph from the hypothetical galaxy data and identify its relationship.
Examine how spectroscopic redshift is used in modern astronomy.
Cross-Curricular Connections
Mathematics: Proportional relationships, graph interpretation, uncertainty, and unit conversion.
History: Scientific debates, technological development, chronology, and attribution.
English Language Arts: Informational reading, evidence-based argumentation, and scientific explanation.
Technology: Digital imaging, astronomical instruments, and data processing.
Career and Technical Education: Scientific calibration, engineering measurement, and research communication.
SEL Connection
Scientific collaboration provides an opportunity to examine intellectual humility, perseverance, professional respect, and the willingness to reconsider earlier assumptions.
Skill Value Emphasis
Students develop transferable abilities in critical reasoning, quantitative literacy, historical inquiry, source evaluation, and communicating conclusions under uncertainty.
Answer Key — Student Worksheet
Hubble originally classified the object as a possible nova. Comparing photographs revealed periodic brightness changes consistent with a Cepheid variable.
Leavitt established a relationship between Cepheid pulsation period and intrinsic luminosity. Astronomers use intrinsic and apparent brightness to calculate distance.
Andromeda was too distant to belong to the Milky Way and was therefore an independent galaxy.
The debate involved competing explanations that could be tested using improved distance measurements.
Appropriate examples include Leavitt's Cepheid research, Slipher's spectroscopy, Lemaître's expanding-universe model, and Humason's observational measurements.
Local gravitational attraction between the Milky Way and Andromeda produces relative motion that can overcome the expansion effect at their separation.
At 10 megaparsecs: 700 km/s. At 20 megaparsecs: 1,400 km/s. At 40 megaparsecs: 2,800 km/s. The model predicts proportional increases; local gravitational motions and measurement uncertainties can produce deviations.
Strong responses distinguish the validity of the extragalactic discovery from errors in the numerical distance scale.
Quiz
Instructions: Select the best answer for each question.
1. What observation allowed Hubble to identify the star in Andromeda as a Cepheid variable?
A. It remained continuously bright over several months.
B. Its brightness changed in a predictable pattern.
C. It produced a sudden explosion and disappeared.
D. It moved rapidly across the photographic plate.
2. Why was Henrietta Swan Leavitt's discovery essential to Hubble's work?
A. It established the chemical composition of Andromeda.
B. It provided evidence that every star has the same luminosity.
C. It connected Cepheid pulsation periods with intrinsic luminosity.
D. It established the speed of light through intergalactic space.
3. What did Hubble's measurement of Andromeda demonstrate?
A. Andromeda was a cloud of gas inside the Milky Way.
B. Andromeda was a separate galaxy beyond the Milky Way.
C. Andromeda contained fewer stars than previously thought.
D. Andromeda was the center of the universe.
4. What relationship is described by the Hubble–Lemaître law?
A. More massive galaxies always rotate faster.
B. More distant galaxies generally show greater recession velocities.
C. Galaxies become smaller as the universe expands.
D. Nearby galaxies necessarily move away from one another.
5. Why is the Andromeda Galaxy approaching the Milky Way?
A. Cosmic expansion has permanently stopped.
B. Andromeda does not contain dark matter.
C. Their mutual gravitational attraction influences their motion.
D. The Hubble–Lemaître law has been disproved.
Assessment
Open-Ended Assessment
Historical and Scientific Reasoning: Explain how Hubble's observations of Andromeda changed astronomy. Incorporate the scientific contributions of at least 3 other individuals and explain why their earlier work was essential.
Evidence and Scientific Revision: Explain the relationship between distance and recession velocity, describe why Hubble's original expansion-rate estimate required correction, and discuss what the continuing Hubble tension reveals about scientific measurement.
3–2–1 Assessment Rubric
Each response receives a score from 1 to 3.
3 — Proficient: Scientifically accurate, clearly reasoned, supported by relevant evidence, and demonstrates an understanding of historical or observational context.
2 — Developing: Mostly accurate, with relevant evidence, but contains incomplete explanations or minor scientific misunderstandings.
1 — Beginning: Limited explanation, insufficient supporting evidence, or substantial misconceptions.
Scoring
Assessment Question 1: Maximum 3 points.
Assessment Question 2: Maximum 3 points.
Total Possible Score: 6 points.
Performance Interpretation
6 points: Strong demonstrated understanding.
4–5 points: Satisfactory understanding with areas for refinement.
2–3 points: Additional instruction and reassessment recommended.
Exit Ticket
Before leaving, students complete these 3 statements:
One observation that transformed astronomy was...
One scientist whose contribution helped make that discovery possible was...
One question astronomers are still investigating is...
Assessment Evidence: Responses must demonstrate scientific accuracy, source-based reasoning, and the ability to distinguish observational evidence from interpretation.
Standards Alignment
NGSS — Next Generation Science Standards
HS-ESS1-2 — Earth's Place in the Universe: Students use evidence from galaxy recession velocities and astronomical spectra to explain observed cosmic expansion. The lesson addresses the expansion and redshift components of this broader performance expectation.
Science and Engineering Practice — Analyzing and Interpreting Data: Students interpret a quantitative distance–velocity relationship and identify limitations of the evidence.
Crosscutting Concept — Patterns: Students identify proportional relationships in astronomical measurements and distinguish general patterns from local exceptions.
CCSS — Common Core State Standards
CCSS Reading
RST.11-12.1 — Cite Specific Textual Evidence: Students support scientific explanations using the episode transcript and historical sources.
RST.11-12.7 — Integrate and Evaluate Multiple Sources: Students compare audio narration, archival imagery, and numerical astronomical evidence.
RST.11-12.8 — Evaluate Hypotheses, Data, and Conclusions: Students assess Hubble's original measurements against modern evidence and explain why numerical revisions occurred.
CCSS Writing
WHST.11-12.2 — Write Informative/Explanatory Texts: Students prepare accurate explanations of Cepheid-based distance measurement and cosmic expansion.
WHST.11-12.7 — Conduct Research Projects: Students investigate a historical astronomical discovery using multiple reliable sources.
WHST.11-12.8 — Gather Relevant Information: Students verify scientific claims and acknowledge authoritative research.
C3 Framework — College, Career, and Civic Life
D2.His.3.9-12 — Change, Continuity, and Context: Students evaluate the historical significance of Hubble's work within the scientific developments of the early 20th century.
D2.His.14.9-12 — Historical Causation: Students explain how advances in instrumentation, measurement, and collaboration contributed to changing astronomical knowledge.
D3.1.9-12 — Gathering and Evaluating Sources: Students compare archival records and contemporary scientific explanations for authority and evidentiary value.
ISTE — International Society for Technology in Education
1.3 — Knowledge Constructor: Students locate, evaluate, and synthesize authoritative astronomical information.
1.3.b — Evaluate Information: Students assess the credibility, accuracy, and relevance of scientific and historical digital sources.
1.5 — Computational Thinker: Students use proportional mathematical relationships to interpret scientific data.
Career and Technical Education — Applied Competencies
Quantitative Reasoning: Calculate and interpret proportional relationships using appropriate units.
Technical Literacy: Explain how astronomical instruments and imaging methods produce measurable observations.
Research and Problem Solving: Evaluate evidence, recognize uncertainty, and revise explanations when better information becomes available.
Scientific Communication: Present technical findings accurately for audiences with different levels of scientific preparation.
UK National Curriculum — Key Stages
KS3 Science — Space Physics Foundations: Students develop understanding of stars, galaxies, and the relative scale of astronomical systems.
KS4 Physics — Space Physics and Redshift: Students explain how galactic redshift supports the expanding-universe model. Alignment is especially applicable to GCSE Physics courses covering space physics.
KS5 Physics — Astrophysics and Cosmology: Students interpret Hubble's law, redshift, and astronomical distance measurements where included in the selected qualification specification.
International Baccalaureate — IB
MYP Sciences, Criterion A — Knowing and Understanding: Students explain scientific terminology, principles, and astronomical observations.
MYP Sciences, Criterion C — Processing and Evaluating: Students interpret distance and velocity data and evaluate limitations.
MYP Sciences, Criterion D — Reflecting on the Impacts of Science: Students evaluate how astronomical discoveries altered scientific understanding.
DP Physics — Scientific Inquiry and Data Analysis: Students use observational evidence and quantitative reasoning to investigate cosmic expansion, where consistent with the course syllabus.
Cambridge International — Secondary and Advanced Studies
IGCSE Physics — Space Physics: Students interpret astronomical observations, galaxy movement, and redshift where covered by the selected syllabus.
AS/A Level Physics — Cosmology and Astronomy: Students apply mathematical models and evaluate the interpretation of observational data where these topics are included.
Bloom's Taxonomy — Cognitive Progression
Remember: Identify scientists, dates, and scientific terminology.
Understand: Explain the significance of Cepheid variables.
Apply: Calculate recession velocities.
Analyze: Compare historical measurements and scientific contributions.
Evaluate: Assess the strength and limitations of astronomical evidence.
Create: Develop a supported explanation of how modern cosmology emerged.
UDL — Universal Design for Learning
Multiple Means of Engagement: Historical mystery, scientific inquiry, discussion, and quantitative challenges.
Multiple Means of Representation: Audio, transcript, archival photograph, numerical data, and mathematical notation.
Multiple Means of Action and Expression: Written explanations, graphical analysis, oral discussion, and structured research.
Homeschool and Lifelong Learning
Independent Inquiry: Learners investigate a historical astronomical discovery using the transcript and referenced research.
Scientific Literacy: Learners distinguish observation, hypothesis, mathematical interpretation, and uncertainty.
Quantitative Understanding: Learners interpret basic astronomical measurements without requiring advanced mathematics.
Self-Directed Assessment: Learners complete comprehension questions, review explanations, and identify areas for further investigation.
Show Notes
Edwin Hubble's 1923 observation of a Cepheid variable star in Andromeda helped establish that the Milky Way was only one galaxy among many. Building on Henrietta Swan Leavitt's research and earlier astronomical observations, Hubble demonstrated that Andromeda lay beyond our galaxy, fundamentally expanding the known scale of the universe. His subsequent work on the relationship between galaxy distance and recession velocity, alongside contributions from Vesto Slipher, Georges Lemaître, and Milton Humason, helped establish modern observational cosmology. This curriculum explores the history, evidence, mathematics, and scientific reasoning behind those discoveries, including the continuing debate over the universe's expansion rate. Students examine how observations become scientific evidence, how discoveries depend on collaboration, and why more accurate measurements can strengthen rather than invalidate scientific understanding.
References
Historical and Scientific Sources
1. Carnegie Science. (n.d.). Hubble's famous M31 VAR! plate. https://carnegiescience.edu/about/history/archives/plate-archives/m31var
2. NASA Hubble Mission Team. (2011, May 23). Hubble views the star that changed the universe. NASA. https://science.nasa.gov/missions/hubble/hubble-views-the-star-that-changed-the-universe/
3. American Astronomical Society. (2021). This month in astronomical history: January 2021. https://aas.org/posts/news/2021/02/month-astronomical-history-january-2021
4. American Physical Society. (2008). Edwin Hubble expands our view of the universe. https://www.aps.org/apsnews/2008/01/edwin-hubble-expands-view-universe
5. OpenStax. (2022). Astronomy 2e: 26.5 The expanding universe. Rice University. https://openstax.org/books/astronomy-2e/pages/26-5-the-expanding-universe
6. International Astronomical Union. (2018, October 29). IAU members vote to recommend renaming the Hubble law as the Hubble–Lemaître law. https://www.iau.org/IAU/Iau/News/PR2018/hubble-lemaitre-law-renamed.aspx
7. NASA. (1994). Hubble Space Telescope measures precise distance to the most remote galaxy yet. https://science.nasa.gov/missions/hubble/hubble-space-telescope-measures-precise-distance-to-the-most-remote-galaxy-yet/
8. NASA. (2025). Hubble constant and tension. https://science.nasa.gov/mission/hubble/science/science-behind-the-discoveries/hubble-constant-and-tension/
9. National Institute of Standards and Technology. (2026). How fast is the universe expanding? https://www.nist.gov/measuring-cosmos/how-fast-universe-expanding
10. NASA. (n.d.). Tracing the growth of galaxies. https://science.nasa.gov/mission/hubble/science/science-highlights/tracing-the-growth-of-galaxies/
11. NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory. (n.d.). Model the expanding universe. https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/edu/resources/lesson-plan/model-the-expanding-universe/