1843: “Sophie Germain’s Borrowed Name”

1843: "Sophie Germain’s Borrowed Name"
JC

Interesting Things with JC #1843: “Sophie Germain’s Borrowed Name”

Sophie Germain sent Carl Friedrich Gauss her mathematics under a man’s name. He praised her work. Then Napoleon’s troops arrived in his town, and Gauss heard a name he didn’t recognize.


Curriculum - Episode Anchor

Series: Interesting Things with JC
Episode Title: Sophie Germain’s Borrowed Name
Episode Number: 1843
Episode Date: Saturday, November 21, 2026
Host: JC
Audience: Grades 9–12, introductory college, homeschool, and lifelong learners
Subject Areas: Mathematics, history of mathematics, and primary source analysis
Essential Question: What can one letter tell us about who could participate in mathematics, and what can one theorem tell us about a problem that was still open?

Lesson Overview

Lesson Length: 45 minutes

Prior Knowledge: Positive whole numbers, factors, multiples, and basic exponent notation

Student Deliverable: A worked prime-number investigation and a short analysis that cites the 1804 letter and a supporting source

Learning Objectives

  • Explain how Germain entered a mathematical exchange with Gauss and trace the events leading to her 1807 disclosure.

  • Test whether a prime p is a Sophie Germain prime by checking whether 2p + 1 is also prime, and justify the result.

  • State exactly what Germain’s result rules out for exponent 11 and identify the type of hypothetical solution it leaves open.

  • Use a dated archival letter and a secondary source to distinguish recorded evidence from historical inference.

Key Vocabulary

  • Pseudonym: A name used in place of one’s own. Germain signed her first letter to Gauss Le Blanc.

  • Primary source: Evidence originating in the period under study. A historical letter is a primary source, and a later archival copy can preserve its words.

  • Exponent: In xn, the number n indicates how many times x appears as a factor when n is a positive whole number.

  • Prime number: A whole number greater than 1 with exactly 2 positive divisors, 1 and itself.

  • Multiple: A number obtained by multiplying another number by an integer. For example, 22 is a multiple of 11.

  • Sophie Germain prime: A prime p for which 2p + 1 is also prime. For p = 11, the second prime is 23.

  • Counterexample: One example that satisfies a claim’s assumptions and shows its conclusion is false.

  • First case of Fermat’s Last Theorem: For a prime exponent p, the case in which none of the 3 numbers in a proposed solution is divisible by p.

Narrative Core

Historical Chronology

  • 1801: Gauss publishes Disquisitiones Arithmeticae, a book on number theory Germain studies closely.

  • November 21, 1804: Germain writes from Paris to Gauss using the name Le Blanc. The letter discusses his book and mentions work on Fermat’s equation.

  • 1806–1807: French troops occupy Braunschweig, where Gauss lives. Germain asks a French general to check on him and discloses her identity to Gauss in 1807.

  • 1820s: Legendre credits Germain’s theorem in a published footnote. Surviving manuscripts document a broader research program.

  • 1995: Andrew Wiles’s proof and a companion paper by Richard Taylor and Wiles appear in Annals of Mathematics.

The Mathematics

32 + 42 = 9 + 16 = 25 = 52. Fermat’s Last Theorem says the equation xn + yn = zn has no solution in positive whole numbers when the whole-number exponent n is greater than 2.

For exponent 11, Germain’s result rules out every proposed solution in which all 3 numbers escape divisibility by 11. Any hypothetical solution would have to include at least one multiple of 11. Cases that include a multiple require further reasoning. The 11 and 23 prime pair makes this restriction available for exponent 11.

Primary Source Reading

Source A: In the archived copy of the first letter, find the date at the top of page 1. Germain tells Gauss that she has studied his book, describes extending a result, and mentions Fermat’s equation. This is an English paraphrase. Open the Institut de France letter PDF.

Source B: Read the MacTutor biography’s account of the correspondence and Germain’s 1807 disclosure. Use it to establish what she later said about taking a borrowed name. Read the MacTutor biography.

Transcript

Historical illustration of Sophie Germain holding a quill over a letter at a window-lit desk. The cover reads “Interesting Things with JC #1843” and “Sophie Germain’s Borrowed Name.”

Historical illustration of Sophie Germain holding a quill over a letter at a window-lit desk. The cover reads “Interesting Things with JC #1843” and “Sophie Germain’s Borrowed Name.”

Interesting Things with JC #1843:

“Sophie Germain’s Borrowed Name”

Read-Aloud Guide: In the French guides, the N in MEHN, BLAHN, and ZHAHN marks a nasal vowel.

On November 21, 1804, a mathematician in Paris wrote to Carl Friedrich Gauss (karl FREE-drihkh GOWSS). The writer had studied his book on number theory and sent him some original mathematics, including work on a problem that had been open for more than 150 years. The letter was signed Le Blanc (luh BLAHN).

The writer was Sophie Germain (soh-FEE zhehr-MEHN). Women couldn’t enroll at the École Polytechnique (ay-KOHL poh-lee-tehk-NEEK), so she got hold of lecture notes and studied them on her own. She used a man’s name to send in her work. After reading that first letter, Gauss wrote to a colleague about how deeply the young mathematician in Paris understood his book.

Then Napoleon’s troops occupied the town where Gauss lived. Germain asked a French general she knew to check on him. Gauss was safe, but when he heard who’d asked after him, he had no idea who Sophie Germain was. In 1807, she wrote to tell him she was Le Blanc. Gauss wrote back praising her talent and the courage it took to pursue the work.

One problem Germain kept coming back to was Fermat’s Last Theorem (Fermat is pronounced fehr-MAH). You can add 3 squared and 4 squared to get 5 squared. Fermat said no 3 positive whole numbers could do that with cubes, fourth powers, or any higher power.

Mathematicians had been tackling those powers one at a time. Germain found a way to rule out a whole class of possible answers across many powers at once. Take the 11th power. Double 11 and add 1, and you get 23. Both numbers are prime. That was enough for her to show that any solution would need at least 1 multiple of 11.

When the French mathematician Legendre (luh-ZHAHNDR) published Germain’s result, he credited her by name in a footnote. Today, 11 is called a Sophie Germain prime.

These are interesting things, with JC.

Student Worksheet

Comprehension and Evidence

  1. Give the writing date and place of Germain’s first letter. Cite Source A and describe one piece of mathematical work Germain discusses there.

  2. What happened between the French occupation of Gauss’s town and Germain’s disclosure in 1807? Use Source B to explain the order of events.

  3. Which source helps explain why Germain used a borrowed name? Identify the evidence behind your answer and say whose account it is.

Mathematical Investigation

  1. Test p = 5, 7, 11, and 13. For each candidate, calculate 2p + 1, explain whether the result is prime, and classify p. For a composite result, give a factorization.

  2. A student claims that any prime p produces another prime when doubled and increased by 1. Use one of your calculations to refute the claim.

  3. Imagine a proposed solution to Fermat’s equation with exponent 11 in which none of the 3 bases is divisible by 11. What does Germain’s result tell you? What would still have to be checked for a different proposed solution that includes a multiple of 11?

Reflection

  1. Write 3–4 sentences explaining what the letter directly documents about Germain’s work and what later correspondence adds about her choice of name. Cite both sources.

Difficulty Scaling

  • Level 1: Provide a list of small primes and read the letter paraphrase alongside the date visible in the archive.

  • Level 2: Have students justify each primality decision and complete the source comparison independently.

  • Level 3: Prove that if an odd prime p leaves remainder 1 on division by 3, then 2p + 1 is composite. Use p = 3 as a separate check of the hypothesis.

Academic Integrity: Credit calculations and explanations produced with outside assistance, identify translated or paraphrased material, and show your own reasoning.

Teacher Guide

Quick Start: Ask students what a dated letter can establish. Play the episode or assign the transcript, then have students use the dated page and the prime examples to test two different kinds of claims.

Pacing Guide — Audio First

  1. 0–5 minutes: Listen or read. Students record the name on the letter and one question about the math.

  2. 5–14 minutes: Examine the letter’s date and the English paraphrase. Compare them with the account of Germain’s disclosure in Source B.

  3. 14–27 minutes: Work through p = 5 together, then test the remaining three candidates in pairs. Ask pairs to justify why 23 is prime.

  4. 27–37 minutes: Complete the worksheet reflection or begin the assessment response. Compare what an archival date establishes with what a theorem establishes.

  5. 37–45 minutes: Administer the quiz and collect an exit sentence stating what Germain’s result establishes for exponent 11.

Materials

  • Episode audio or transcript, Sources A and B, paper or a shared document, and an optional calculator.

Formative Checkpoints

  • Source check: The dateline gives the writing date. Finding a receipt date would require separate evidence.

  • Calculation check: For 23, trial division by 2 and 3 suffices because the next prime, 5, exceeds the square root of 23.

  • Scope check: Look for “at least one multiple of 11” in student explanations of a hypothetical solution.

Differentiation

  • Additional Support: Model the expression 2p + 1 with one substitution and provide a factor-check scaffold.

  • Multilingual Learners: Pair the dated French page with the English paraphrase, and provide a vocabulary bank for prime, multiple, and pseudonym.

  • Advanced Learners: Use the worksheet’s remainder proof, then write a sentence explaining which primes its hypothesis excludes.

  • Accessibility: Offer the text transcript and plain-language paraphrase alongside the audio and handwritten scan. Accept written, typed, or spoken responses using the same evidence criteria.

Worksheet Answer Guide

  1. Paris, November 21, 1804. Page 1 discusses extending a result from Gauss’s book and mentions Fermat’s equation.

  2. French troops occupied Gauss’s town. Germain asked a general to check on him, and later told Gauss that she was Le Blanc.

  3. Source B quotes Germain’s later account, in which she describes taking the name because she feared ridicule as a woman pursuing science.

  4. 5: 11, prime. 7: 15 = 3 × 5, composite. 11: 23, prime. 13: 27 = 3 × 9, composite. Only 5 and 11 qualify among these candidates.

  5. For p = 7, the output is 15, which is composite. This disproves the universal claim.

  6. The theorem rules out the first candidate. In the separate case involving a multiple of 11, further reasoning must determine whether the equation could actually be satisfied.

  7. A complete response cites the 1804 letter for the date and mathematical work, then uses Source B’s account of the later correspondence for the explanation of the pseudonym.

Advanced Solution: Write p = 3k + 1. Then 2p + 1 = 3(2k + 1), a multiple of 3 greater than 3 for the primes covered by the hypothesis. The prime 3 leaves remainder 0 and produces 7.

Quiz

Student Directions: Answer in one sentence or show a calculation. Each question is worth 1 point.

  1. Who signed the letter to Gauss as Le Blanc?

  2. What does the date November 21, 1804 document about the first letter?

  3. Is 7 a Sophie Germain prime? Show the calculation that supports your answer.

  4. Why is 11 a Sophie Germain prime?

  5. What divisibility condition would any hypothetical solution with exponent 11 need to satisfy?

Answer Key

  1. Sophie Germain.

  2. It is the date Germain wrote the letter, recorded in its dateline.

  3. No. 2 × 7 + 1 = 15, and 15 = 3 × 5.

  4. 11 is prime, and 2 × 11 + 1 = 23 is prime.

  5. At least one of the 3 numbers would have to be divisible by 11.

Assessment

Performance Task: Create a short museum label or record a 60–90 second audio guide about Germain’s letter and her mathematics. Use a detail from Source A and a detail from Source B to connect the letter to the disclosure. Include the 11 and 23 calculation and explain exactly which set of hypothetical solutions is ruled out.

Evidence to Submit: Provide both citations, the worked calculation, and one sentence describing what remains to be addressed for exponent 11.

3–2–1 Scoring Rubric

  • 3 points — Proficient: Accurately uses both sources, shows why 11 and 23 form the required prime pair, and distinguishes the ruled-out first case from proposed solutions involving a multiple of 11.

  • 2 points — Developing: Gives the correct chronology or mathematics, with one substantial gap in sourcing, calculation, or explanation of the theorem’s scope.

  • 1 point — Beginning: Names Germain or the mathematical problem, with multiple gaps in evidence, calculation, or interpretation.

Standards Alignment

Common Core State Standards — Mathematics and Literacy

  • MP3 — Construct viable arguments and critique the reasoning of others: Students counter a universal claim with p = 7 and justify their primality classifications. Evidence is the worked calculation and explanation in Worksheet 4–5. Official MP3 standard.

  • RH.9–10.1 — Cite specific textual evidence from primary and secondary sources: Students cite the dateline in Source A and identify the origin of the explanation in Source B. Evidence is the source comparison in Worksheet 1–3 and 7. Official RH.9–10.1 standard.

C3 Framework — History

  • D2.His.1.9–12 — Historical context: Students explain how access to formal study and French military occupation shaped separate stages of the correspondence. Evidence is a correctly sequenced explanation that cites the historical account. National Council for the Social Studies guidance.

England National Curriculum — Mathematics

Show Notes

Episode Summary: Sophie Germain sent her mathematics to Carl Friedrich Gauss under a borrowed name. Their correspondence reveals how she entered a scholarly exchange and how she narrowed the search for solutions to Fermat’s equation.

Series Website: https://JimConnors.net

Cover Art Alt Text: Cover art for Interesting Things with JC #1843, Sophie Germain’s Borrowed Name. A historical re-creation shows Germain holding a quill to a letter at a window-lit desk.

References

  • Germain, Sophie. Letter to Carl Friedrich Gauss, November 21, 1804. Verified copy held by the Institut de France, MS 2031, item 89. Source A. Institut de France digitized letter.

  • O’Connor, J. J., and E. F. Robertson. “Sophie Germain.” MacTutor History of Mathematics, University of St Andrews. Source B. https://mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk/Biographies/Germain/

  • “Comptes rendus et analyses.” Bulletin des sciences mathématiques et astronomiques (1880 review of Boncompagni’s edition of the correspondence, p. 273). Records the signature of Germain’s first letter. Numdam digitized review.

  • Darmon, Henri, Fred Diamond, and Richard Taylor. “Fermat’s Last Theorem.” Historical and mathematical exposition of the prime exponent result and its first-case scope. McGill University hosted paper.

  • Laubenbacher, Reinhard, and David Pengelley. “Voici ce que j’ai trouvé: Sophie Germain’s grand plan to prove Fermat’s Last Theorem.” Historia Mathematica 37, no. 4 (2010), pp. 641–692. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hm.2009.12.002

  • Wiles, Andrew. “Modular Elliptic Curves and Fermat’s Last Theorem.” Companion paper by Richard Taylor and Andrew Wiles, “Ring-Theoretic Properties of Certain Hecke Algebras.” Annals of Mathematics 141, no. 3 (May 1995), pp. 443–551 and 553–572. May 1995 issue contents.

Next
Next

1842: "Edwin Hubble"