1844: "Who Gets to Decide What the Public Can Know?"

1844: "Who Gets to Decide What the Public Can Know?"
JC

Interesting Things with JC #1844: "Who Gets to Decide What the Public Can Know?"

In 2018, the Croatian Wikipedia entry on Jasenovac dropped “death camp” from its opening paragraph. The article was still there for anyone to read. In Washington, a reporter could cover Congress but couldn’t get a White House press pass. At Kentucky State University, students could print a yearbook their classmates never got to open.


Curriculum - Episode Anchor

Series: Interesting Things with JC
Episode #1844: Who Gets to Decide What the Public Can Know?
Host: Jim Connors (JC)
Audience: Grades 9–12, introductory college, homeschool, and lifelong learners
Subject Areas: Civics, journalism, history, and media literacy
Episode Runtime: Approximately 4 minutes, 10 seconds at 107 words per minute
Lesson Time: 50 minutes
Essential Question: How can we tell who shaped a public account, what their decision kept people from learning, and where to look for evidence?

Lesson Overview

A reporter can read every word of a briefing transcript and still come away missing something: the answer to a question he would have asked. A student can find the encyclopedia article she needs without realizing that someone removed a crucial description. This lesson asks students to investigate omissions that are easy to overlook precisely because the document in front of them appears complete.

Students examine 2 American press disputes and a historical example from Croatian Wikipedia. They identify who made each decision, when it affected the flow of information, and which evidence can help a reader evaluate it.

Learning Objectives

By the end of the lesson, students can:

  • Distinguish a restriction on gathering news from suppression of a finished publication.

  • Use a factual detail from each court case to explain why the identity and authority of the decision maker mattered.

  • Explain how historically authentic wording can mislead when an editor removes essential context.

  • Choose an appropriate source to verify an editorial change and a separate source to investigate the underlying historical event.

Success Criterion: A student can answer 3 questions about each example: Who acted? What became harder for the public to learn? How do we know?

Key Vocabulary

  • Press credential: A pass recognizing a journalist for access to particular facilities or events. Robert Sherrill held congressional credentials and still had to apply separately for White House access.

  • Newsgathering: Obtaining information through observation, interviews, records, and questions. An opportunity to ask a follow-up is part of newsgathering.

  • Editorial discretion: Authority to decide what a publication includes and how it presents material. Student editor Capri Coffer exercised editorial discretion when she chose what belonged in the yearbook.

  • Censorship: An exercise of power that restricts expression or its circulation. Confiscating an entire print run can suppress a publication without altering a word.

  • Government action: Conduct attributable to a public authority. The White House and officials at a public university exercised government power in the American disputes.

  • Due process: Procedural protections that apply to certain government decisions. In Sherrill’s case, they included notice of the factual grounds for denial, a chance to respond, and written reasons for the final decision.

  • Corroboration: Checking a claim against independently grounded evidence. Which evidence to consult depends on the claim being tested.

  • Historical denial: Rejecting or minimizing documented events despite the evidence. Students can distinguish denial from legitimate historical revision by examining the quality of the sources and how a writer handles contrary evidence.

Narrative Core

The reader’s problem

The opening turns on 2 missing words. A student searching for Jasenovac (YAH-seh-noh-vahts) would still find an article bearing the correct name. Nothing about finding that page would tell the student that its introduction had changed. The first historical question is therefore quite narrow: What did this particular edition tell its readers at this particular time?

Historical chronology

  1. 1966 — White House access. Robert Sherrill, a Washington correspondent for The Nation, is denied a White House press pass. Other reporters can attend and ask questions. Sherrill’s readers depend on someone else in the room recognizing what needs a follow-up.

  2. 1977 — The Sherrill ruling. A federal appeals court recognizes presidential security as a compelling concern and examines what the government owes an otherwise eligible reporter when it denies access to established press facilities. The court requires meaningful procedures for challenging the decision.

  3. 1994 — The Kentucky State yearbook. A university official objects to the student yearbook’s purple cover, missing photo captions, and national news content. The university withholds the completed books. The official intervenes after the students have made their editorial decisions and the printer has produced the copies.

  4. 2000–2001 — The books remain in storage. Reporting in 2000 documents that the books are still locked away. In 2001, the full federal appeals court concludes that university officials violated the students’ First Amendment rights in the circumstances of this publication.

  5. 2018 — The Jasenovac introduction changes. An introduction on Croatian Wikipedia describes Jasenovac as a collection and labor camp and drops the reference to a death camp. The wartime regime itself used an administrative name associated with labor. Repeating that wording without explaining the mass murder distorts what a new reader understands.

  6. 2021 — The editorial record is examined. A Wikimedia-commissioned external assessment documents the treatment of historical evidence and the exclusion of contributors who challenged the editors. The group’s leaders lose administrator privileges. The assessment preserves evidence about the editing dispute; the memorial preserves documentation about the victims.

The distinction students should carry forward

The White House decision affected who could gather information. The university decision affected whether a finished publication reached readers. The Wikipedia decision affected the historical account readers encountered. The American cases raise constitutional questions about government authority. The encyclopedia example asks who exercised private editorial power and whether the published account stands up to the evidence.

Transcript

Cover for Interesting Things with JC #1844, “Who Gets to Decide What the Public Can Know?” An illustration shows purple yearbooks stacked behind the wire-glass window of a dark green storeroom door secured with a brass padlock.

Cover for Interesting Things with JC #1844, “Who Gets to Decide What the Public Can Know?” An illustration shows purple yearbooks stacked behind the wire-glass window of a dark green storeroom door secured with a brass padlock.

Interesting Things with JC #1844:

"Who Gets to Decide What the Public Can Know?"

In 2018, 2 words disappeared from the opening paragraph of an article on the Croatian edition of Wikipedia. The words were “death camp.” A student looking up Jasenovac (YAH-seh-noh-vahts) for the first time could still find the article under the same name. But now the opening described it as a labor camp. How would that student even know to ask what had been left out?

Who gets to decide what the public can know? In Washington, that decision can come as early as choosing which reporters get into a briefing.

In 1966, Robert Sherrill covered Washington for The Nation. He held press credentials for both houses of Congress. When he applied for a White House pass, the Secret Service turned him down on security grounds. Sherrill could read a transcript afterward. What he couldn’t do from his desk was ask the follow-up his readers might have wanted answered.

In 1977, a federal appeals court recognized the government’s duty to protect the president. Once the White House opened its press facilities to journalists, though, it needed a compelling reason to exclude a qualified reporter. Sherrill had a right to know what facts the decision rested on, a chance to respond, and a written explanation of the final decision.

At Kentucky State University, the decision came after the presses ran. Student editor Capri Coffer chose a purple yearbook cover for a school whose colors were green and gold. A university official objected to the cover, the missing photo captions, and the national news Coffer had included. She confiscated every copy. Six years later, the books were still locked in a storeroom. The university had given students editorial control. In 2001, a federal appeals court ruled that officials at this public university had violated the First Amendment by withholding the books.

The First Amendment limits government power. The people who changed the account of Jasenovac were private editors. A review commissioned by Wikimedia found that nationalist editors had banned contributors who challenged them. The article gave Holocaust deniers’ claims as much weight as historical research. And those words the student read, “labor camp,” echoed the wartime regime’s own name for a place where it murdered Serbs, Jews, Roma, and others.

Volunteers kept challenging those edits. In 2021, the group’s leaders lost their administrator privileges. Today, that student can open the article’s history and see when the wording changed. Then they can search the camp memorial’s records by a victim’s name, birthplace, even their father’s name. Those editors decided what the student saw first. They could change the opening paragraph. They couldn’t erase the names the memorial had preserved.

These are interesting things, with JC.


Student Worksheet

Comprehension

  1. Sherrill could still read a briefing transcript. Identify one opportunity he lost and explain how that loss could affect someone who read his reporting.

  2. Who chose the yearbook’s purple cover? Who decided that students could not receive their copies? Explain why these were different exercises of authority.

Source Analysis

  1. Read the opening of the majority opinion and the factual background in Kincaid v. Gibson [2]. Who wrote the opinion? What did the court decide? Identify one fact about how the yearbook was produced that helps explain the ruling.

  2. Find the discussion of the August 2018 introduction in the Wikimedia assessment [4]. Compare it with the memorial’s description of Jasenovac [5]. Record the wording that appeared, the information that disappeared from the introduction, and one thing the memorial documents about the prisoners. Why might the regime’s own terminology mislead a reader even if it is quoted accurately?

  3. A classmate says, “All 3 decisions limited what people could learn, so all 3 violated the U.S. First Amendment.” Respond using the identity of each decision maker and one factual detail from each example.

Reflection

  1. Someone sends you a screenshot of an old encyclopedia paragraph. Describe one check you would make before saying the paragraph was changed. Describe a different check you would make before repeating its claim about the past.

Difficulty Scaling

  • Level 1: Complete the frame: “___ made the decision. It affected readers because ___. I can check this in ___.”

  • Level 2: Answer all 6 questions. For questions 3 and 4, record a page number, section heading, or dated revision so another reader can find your evidence.

  • Level 3: Explain how a document can be strong evidence for what readers encountered in 2018 and weak evidence for what happened during World War II.

Student Output: Six responses, followed by the individual writing task in the Assessment section.
Academic Integrity Guidance: Put copied wording in quotation marks. Attribute paraphrases. Distinguish what a source states from what you infer.

Teacher Guide

Quick Start

Ask students, “Suppose I give you an accurate transcript of every answer at a briefing. What information might you still be missing?” Keep 2 student answers visible. After the episode, ask which answer best explains what Sherrill’s readers lost.

Pacing Guide — Audio First

  1. 0–5 minutes: Discuss the opening prompt. Distinguish a question that went unanswered from a question nobody in the room asked.

  2. 5–10 minutes: Play the episode or read the transcript. Students jot down who made each of the 3 decisions.

  3. 10–18 minutes: Complete worksheet questions 1–2. Ask a pair to distinguish choosing a cover from withholding a print run.

  4. 18–30 minutes: In pairs, examine the yearbook opinion and compare the Croatian Wikipedia assessment with the memorial records. Complete questions 3–4.

  5. 30–38 minutes: Discuss questions 5–6 orally and administer the short quiz.

  6. 38–50 minutes: Students complete the individual editor’s note. Collect it with their source references.

Materials

  • Episode audio or printed transcript.

  • Student worksheet and quiz.

  • Opening and factual background of Kincaid v. Gibson [2].

  • Assessment excerpt discussing the August 2018 Jasenovac introduction [4].

  • Memorial introduction and victim database search fields [5]. Printed excerpts work for offline instruction.

Worksheet Answer Guide

  1. Sherrill could work with records and available transcripts. He lost the opportunity to hear an answer firsthand and pursue a question another reporter might overlook. A reader might therefore never receive the resulting information.

  2. Coffer chose the cover as student editor. A university official withheld the completed books. The first decision concerned the contents of a publication; the second prevented its distribution.

  3. Judge R. Guy Cole Jr. wrote the majority opinion. The court found that university officials violated the students’ First Amendment rights. Students produced the yearbook and exercised editorial control with limited advice. The university’s funding was one fact in the case; it did not, by itself, resolve who controlled the publication.

  4. The 2018 wording foregrounded collection and labor and omitted the death-camp identification from the introduction. The memorial documents people killed at the camp and maintains individual victim records. An administrative label can accurately reproduce a perpetrator’s language while obscuring what happened to prisoners.

  5. Sherrill challenged government restrictions on access and the procedures used to deny a pass. Kentucky State officials at a public university suppressed a student publication after printing. The Croatian Wikipedia example involved private editors, historical distortion, and the treatment of evidence. The U.S. court rulings do not supply a verdict on that editorial dispute.

  6. Compare authenticated, dated revisions or the versions documented in the assessment. Then investigate the historical claim independently using the memorial’s documentation and the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum’s account.

Differentiation and Historical Care

  • Additional support: Provide the transcript and allow oral rehearsal. Have students underline the decision maker and circle the action in each example.

  • English learners: Preview press pass, grounds for denial, and editorial control. Ask students to restate each phrase in everyday language.

  • Advanced learners: Use Sherrill v. Knight to distinguish the First Amendment interest in newsgathering from the procedural protections discussed in the opinion. [1]

  • Homeschool and independent study: Complete question 4 before reading the answer guide. Explain aloud why the 2 sources answer different questions.

  • Holocaust education: Establish the documented killings through the memorial and museum sources. Examine how the article gave unsupported claims undue weight. Keep the discussion grounded in evidence and the lives represented by the records. [5, 6]

Quiz

  1. Which action directly restricted newsgathering?
    A. Choosing a yearbook cover. B. Denying a correspondent a White House pass. C. Checking a memorial record. D. Reading an earlier article revision.

  2. Name 2 procedural protections discussed in the Sherrill decision.

  3. Which fact helps explain the yearbook ruling?
    A. Kentucky State was a private university. B. The court preferred the purple cover. C. The university had entrusted editorial decisions to students. D. The printer owned the editorial rights.

  4. Which source best establishes how the Croatian Wikipedia introduction changed in 2018?
    A. A wartime photograph. B. A visitor’s recollection. C. The yearbook opinion. D. Dated article versions documented in the Wikimedia assessment.

  5. Once you verify the encyclopedia edit, why would you still consult the Jasenovac Memorial Site? Answer in one sentence.

Answer Key

  1. B. The credential affected the reporter’s opportunity to gather information firsthand.

  2. Any 2: Notice of the factual grounds for denial, an opportunity to respond, or written reasons for the final decision.

  3. C. The way editorial responsibility had been assigned was relevant to the court’s analysis.

  4. D. Comparing dated versions supplies evidence of a change in wording.

  5. Sample answer: The versions establish what the article said; the memorial provides separately grounded evidence about the people imprisoned and killed at the camp.

Scoring: 1 point per question, 5 points total. Question 2 requires 2 distinct protections for credit.

Assessment

Performance Task

Write a 150–200 word editor’s note answering the episode’s title question. Explain when the White House and Kentucky State decisions affected reporting or publication. Then explain how a reader could investigate the Jasenovac edit. Cite one court opinion, the Wikimedia assessment, and one source about the camp. Finish by identifying a question that one of your sources cannot answer on its own.

3–2–1 Rubric

  • Historical and legal accuracy: 3 — Correctly identifies all 3 decision makers and distinguishes access, distribution, and editorial wording. 2 — Accurately distinguishes 2 examples. 1 — Accurately identifies 1.

  • Use of evidence: 3 — Uses a relevant, attributed detail from all 3 requested source types. 2 — Does so for 2 source types. 1 — Does so for 1.

  • Reasoning: 3 — Explains a specific consequence for readers and a meaningful limit of the evidence. 2 — Explains one and mentions the other. 1 — Offers a general conclusion without developing either point.

Score: Up to 9 points. Award 0 in a category when no relevant work is present.
Revision Prompt: Underline the sentence in which you connect evidence to your conclusion. Could another reader use your citation to test that sentence?

Standards Alignment

Common Core — Reading in History and Social Studies, Grades 9–12

  • CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RH.9-10.1 — Cite evidence and attend to its origin. In worksheet questions 3–4, students identify who produced a source, when it was created, and which detail supports their conclusion. A successful response uses the 2001 Kincaid opinion to establish what the court decided and the dated Wikipedia revision to establish what readers saw in 2018. https://www.thecorestandards.org/ELA-Literacy/RH/9-10/ Common Core State Standards Initiative

  • CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RH.11-12.1 — Connect specific details to an interpretation of the whole text. Students explain why the university’s decision to entrust the yearbook to student editors helps make sense of the court’s ruling. Naming the purple cover demonstrates recall. Explaining who had authority to choose it demonstrates analysis. Assess worksheet question 3 and the editor’s note. https://www.thecorestandards.org/ELA-Literacy/RH/11-12/ www.thecorestandards.org

  • CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RH.11-12.9 — Integrate sources and identify discrepancies. For worksheet question 4, students bring together the 2018 introduction documented in the Wikimedia assessment and the Jasenovac Memorial Site’s account. A strong response identifies the omitted reference to mass killing and explains how that omission changes what a first-time reader would understand. https://www.thecorestandards.org/ELA-Literacy/RH/11-12/ www.thecorestandards.org

Common Core — Evidence-Based Writing, Grades 9–12

C3 Framework — Civics and Constitutional Reasoning

  • D2.Civ.4.9-12 — Powers, responsibilities, and limits of government. Worksheet question 5 asks students to test the claim that all 3 disputes violated the U.S. First Amendment. Look for 3 distinctions: the White House controlled access to established press facilities, public university officials withheld a student publication, and private Wikipedia editors controlled article wording. A successful answer explains why the identity of the decision maker changes the constitutional question, even when each decision affects what readers can learn. https://www.whitehousehistory.org/nationals/how-to-start/learning-standards White House Historical Association

ISTE Standards for Students — Digital and Media Literacy

  • 1.3.b — Evaluate digital information. Worksheet question 6 asks students what they would do with a screenshot of an old encyclopedia entry. Assess whether they propose 2 distinct checks: locate the dated revision to authenticate the wording, then consult independently grounded historical records to evaluate the claim. A student who finds the original screenshot has answered only the first question. https://iste.org/standards/students 1. Students

England — Historical Enquiry and Interpretation

International Programmes — Source Evaluation

Introductory College — ACRL Framework for Information Literacy

  • Authority Is Constructed and Contextual. In the editor’s note, students match each claim to a source equipped to answer it: the judicial opinion for what the court held, the revision evidence for what changed on the page, and the memorial’s documentation for evidence about victims. Assess the final sentence for a specific limit on what one source can establish. https://www.ala.org/acrl/standards/ilframework Association of College and Research Libraries

  • Research as Inquiry. Assess whether the student’s first finding leads to a better second question. For this episode, “Did the wording change?” can be answered by comparing versions. “What evidence was obscured by that change?” requires a different investigation. Worksheet questions 4 and 6 make that progression visible. https://www.ala.org/acrl/standards/ilframework

Show Notes

Episode Summary: A White House correspondent can read the transcript but cannot ask a follow-up. A student editor can produce a yearbook her classmates never receive. A reader can find an encyclopedia article without realizing what disappeared from its introduction. Episode #1844 follows each decision back to the person or institution that made it.

Listening Prompt: At what point does each decision affect you as a reader: when someone gathers the facts, when a publication reaches you, or when you encounter the words on the page?

Cover Art Alt Text: Cover for Interesting Things with JC #1844, “Who Gets to Decide What the Public Can Know?” Purple yearbooks sit behind the wire-glass window of a dark green storeroom door secured with a brass padlock.

Series and Open Curriculum: https://jimconnors.net

References

  1. U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. Sherrill v. Knight, 569 F.2d 124 (1977). Use the opinion to examine the government’s security interest, the journalist’s interest in access, and the procedures for denying a credential. https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F2/569/124/35083/

  2. U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. Kincaid v. Gibson (2001), en banc opinion. The opening and Part I.A identify the ruling, the students’ roles, and the university’s relationship to the yearbook. https://www.opn.ca6.uscourts.gov/opinions.pdf/01a0005p-06.pdf

  3. Student Press Law Center. May 2000 reporting on the Kentucky State case documents that the yearbooks remained locked in a university storeroom while the litigation continued. https://splc.org/2000/05/appellate-court-hears-arguments-in-kincaid-v-gibson-collegecensorship-case/

  4. Wikimedia-commissioned external assessment. Croatian Wikipedia Disinformation Assessment (2021). Search the report for “August 2018” to locate its comparison of introductions to the Jasenovac article. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/14/Croatian_WP_Disinformation_Assessment_-_Final_Report_EN.pdf

  5. Jasenovac Memorial Site. The memorial explains how it compiled its list of individual victims. The search interface shows which details a reader can use to locate a record. https://www.jusp-jasenovac.hr/Default.aspx?sid=6711 · https://www.jusp-jasenovac.hr/Default.aspx?sid=7620

  6. United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. “Jasenovac,” Holocaust Encyclopedia. Historical account of the camp complex, the people imprisoned there, and the mass killings. https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/jasenovac

Next
Next

1843: “Sophie Germain’s Borrowed Name”